Cookie Pricing Guide

Basic

Starting at $4.50 per cookie

This tier includes clean, minimal designs with a charming, understated look. Ideal for party favors, classroom treats, or events where elegance lies in simplicity. These cookies use basic shapes and light detail for maximum impact with minimal fuss.

1–2 icing colors
Minimal piping or detail
No hand-cut shapes
No writing, florals, or metallics

Perfect for when you want something sweet, simple, and still special.

Minimum order of 12 cookies

Detailed

Starting at $6.00 per cookie

This tier steps up the sophistication, offering moderate detail, layered textures, and customized elements. Great for birthdays, showers, and events that need a bit more flair and personalization.

3–4 icing colors
Moderate piping and layering
Some custom shapes
Basic florals or lettering

These cookies bring personality and polish without going over the top.

Minimum order of 12 cookies

Elaborate

Starting at $7.00+ per cookie

For showstopping designs that look as good as they taste, this tier is where art and indulgence meet. From custom illustrations to metallic accents and detailed floral work, these are the cookies you order when only the best will do.

6+ icing colors
Intricate piping and multi-layered details
Brand or logo matching
Hand-cut shapes and full customization
Metallics, florals, logos, characters, script, printing, airbrush

Ideal for weddings, luxury events, brand sets, or when you want to wow.

Minimum order of 12 cookies

Choosing the Right Fit

Design tiers are based on complexity, but cookie size affects both price and presentation. Most of our cookies fall between 3 and 4 inches, just the right size to feel special without being oversized.

Petite and XL options are available upon request, but the pricing listed applies to standard 3–4" cookies unless otherwise discussed.

Because with cookies, like all good things, the size should suit the moment.

Our Prices Reflect More Than Ingredients

At Butter & Hearth, every detail matters. The way the dough is created by careful hands, the quiet care folded into every batch, the packaging that feels like a gift, even when it’s just breakfast. We don’t rush through what we make. We build it with time, with thought, with heart, and whole lot of butter.

Yes, you can find something cheaper at the store. But you won’t find this. Not the warmth, not the story, not the feeling that someone made it just for you. That’s the niche we fill: bakes that feel like comfort, celebration, and intention all wrapped into one.

Our prices reflect the early mornings, the tested recipes, the quality ingredients, and the kind of care that doesn’t cut corners. We don’t discount what we do because we won’t discount the experience of the people we do it for. We believe in honoring the effort behind the work and the meaning behind every bite.

If you’re here, chances are you believe in that too. And we’re so glad you found us.

Contact

Get in touch to learn more.